Brands aren’t children. Although sometimes you’d think they were.
They don’t go through the universal stages, and they don’t reach maturity simply because they’ve spent a long time doing what they do.
—Really?
First-year classes were in the afternoon and ran past 8 pm.
The faculty building was right next to the bar district. First year away from home. Quite the breeding ground, and certainly not the best conditions for keeping up with everything.
Developmental Psychology was the last class of the day, during the first semester. Winter timetable. Hardly any daylight left.
Piaget.
Those stages, plenty of schemas, a Swiss gentleman watching his own children grow up and boxing the whole thing into a system. I thought it was a coñazo.
Object permanence. Conservation. A kid looking at the taller glass and swearing it has more water in it.
I’m not much of a Piaget person. But there’s something in his theory that keeps coming back to me, like a good aioli. Not so much the stages, with their ages and boundaries, but what allows us to move from one to another.
But one thing at a time.
First, the baby.
For that pair of chubby cheeks, the entire world is everything they can touch, grab or shove into their mouth. That’s all.
No symbols. None.
And anyway, at some point, the baby learns something: things still exist even when they’re out of sight.
This is what’s called object permanence. Which means something as obvious as the world no longer disappearing every time the baby closes their eyes.
That’s the baby.
And our babies? Brands?
Good.
A brand still in nappies, even if it’s been doing business for 30 years, doesn’t know much about itself either. It does things, sells, reacts, shows up. It still doesn’t have a narrative to support what it does.
And it believes that if it stops showing up, it disappears.
It confuses being present with existing. It doesn’t yet know what remains of it when nobody’s watching.
—Oops.
The baby grows, fuelled by plenty of good milk bottles.
Then come the symbols: language, pretend play, the ability to represent something that isn’t right in front of them.
But the child still struggles to see the world from a point of view other than their own. They cover their eyes and think you can’t see them, even with half their body sticking out from behind the sofa.
—Peekaboo!
They also confuse appearance with reality.
—Got your nose! I hold it between my fingers. Then I’ll keep it for a while.
Now, take that into branding.
This is the stage where brands have learned to represent themselves, but not necessarily to know themselves, so…
They’ve got the name, the logo, the colours, a story to tell. A good one, because there’s always a good one behind. They talk about themselves, often convinced that everyone else sees exactly what they want them to see. And they look in the mirror.
—Oh, look at me!
They invest so much time looking in the mirror that they end up confusing the reflection with the real object.
Probably, that’s why they think changing the logo means changing their identity. Or why they launch a new narrative and consider the problem solved. So they keep on covering their eyes while half their body is still sticking out from behind the sofa.
And then, then comes conservation.
The kid understands that the amount of water stays the same even when you pour it into a taller and narrower glass.
The appearance changes. Yet the quantity stays the same.
The kids also begin to consider other points of view and reason about concrete relationships. They’re no longer relying entirely on how things look at first glance.
—Let me think a little more. Not so close.
For a brand, that’s one hell of a leap.
Knowing you’re worth the same even when someone changes your glass.
The format, the packaging, the context. All the stuff.
Confusing recognition with identity?
No way. Not anymore.
You understand that your customer doesn’t necessarily see what you see when you look at yourself. That your product occupies a place in their life, and not necessarily the one you’ve carefully assigned to it in slide 17 of your brand presentation.
Bold font, please.
But reasoning is still pretty much tied to the concrete. The product, the category, what the brand already knows how to do. Because that’s how we’ve always done it.
Let’s continue.
A couple of inches taller, the child develops the ability to think abstractly.
Then, imagining hypotheses. Playing with “what if”. Thinking about thinking itself.
The child no longer needs the object right in front of them to be able to think about it. And, of course, getting your first magic set for Christmas that year.
So here’s the kicker: when a brand develops that ability, it can start asking questions it hadn’t even considered before.
What are we, and what could we do tomorrow if we stopped making this? What would still be recognisable if we moved into another category or market?
What could we do that we haven’t even imagined yet?
—Fuck, Lines. You’re intense today.
Yep. And we haven’t even got to the good bit. Because if there’s something that interests me even more than the stages, it’s equilibration.
Piaget used this concept to explain how we reorganise our mental schemas when what we know is no longer enough.
When equilibration happens, we reorganise through two movements: assimilation and accommodation.
Assimilation means incorporating something new into what we already know.
Accommodation means changing what we know because the new thing doesn’t fit our existing schemas.
Forget what I said yesterday. Today I'm saying something else.
In other words, sometimes we manage to understand the world without changing the way we think too much. Other times, the world forces us to change it, whether we like it or not.
So which one’s the good one? Or the least bad?
The truth is we need both.
When a brand only assimilates, it interprets every new development through what it already knows. Everything confirms that it’s right.
The market changes, people change, conversations change, but it keeps finding ways to shove everything into the same drawer.
—It’s always been that way. Indeed.
So then, the brand becomes stiffer than your neck after an eight-hour flight in economy.
—Good, smart girl. And on the other hand?
Ok. The brand that only accommodates?
It changes shape every time something moves outside.
A competitor does this? Wait. The market wants that? Let me check. Change my mind. And what about that new trend? And don’t forget about the algorithm. It changes again.
Here we go!
Headfirst.
It becomes so adaptable it ends up unrecognisable, until not even its founder knows it.
—This is not my baby. Sniff sniff.
Maturing isn’t about choosing between staying still and changing. Peak immature.
So then?
Maturing is about learning to discern.
That’s all.
It seems easy, isn’t it?
Maturing is telling what deserves to remain and what needs to change. Without hesitation, like the second tequila.
Brands aren’t children. But there’s one thing they do, just like children.
They can get caught in that unique way of understanding themselves.
They can repeat schemas that stopped serving them long ago. They can confuse what they are with what they do, and what they show, or what other people expect them to be.
And no. I’m still not much of a Piaget person.
Anyway, here’s your nose.
I give it back.
Lines Aja
Brand Strategist & Verbal Identity Consultant — Las Musas®
weareprimos.com




